Not All Prospects are The Same

Not all prospects deserve your time. A big deal and a small deal take the same effort to close—so why chase the wrong ones?

PRODUCTIVITY & TIME MANAGEMENTSALES STRATEGIES & TACTICS FOCUSED

Patrick Mersinger

10/6/20212 min read

Not all prospects deserve your time. A big deal and a small deal take the same effort to close—so why chase the wrong ones?

Successful sellers do not treat all prospects equally. Instead, they prioritize the right opportunities using a simple, six-step system.

Instead of wasting time, take action. Here is how to identify, rank, and close high-value prospects faster.

1. Define Your Best Clients

🔹 Look at your top customers. What do they have in common?
🔹 Identify 3 to 8 criteria that make them ideal (e.g., org size, decision speed, industry fit).
🔹 Align your prospecting strategy with these success factors.

📌 Example: If your goal is to close large deals, prioritize prospects with bigger budgets and a proven need.

2. Build a Simple Ranking System

🔹 Create an easy-to-follow rating scale:
✔ 1-5 stars, hot-cold, or a simple point system (higher = better).
🔹 Score prospects based on your key criteria.
🔹 Higher scores = higher-priority prospects.

📌 Example: If "fast sales cycle" is a key factor, rank prospects based on their typical buying speed.

3. Score & Sort Your Prospect List

🔹 Assign a score to each prospect.
🔹 Sort your list from highest to lowest scores.
🔹 Divide them into tiers (e.g., 30+ points = Tier 1, 16-30 points = Tier 2, 1-15 points = Tier 3).

📌 Top-tier prospects get priority. Lower tiers? Deprioritize or remove.

4. Find Common Patterns

🔹 Review your highest-scoring prospects.
🔹 Look for patterns in industry, size, decision-making, and urgency.
🔹 If no clear patterns emerge, reassess your ranking criteria.

📌 Example: If most high-scoring prospects share a single point of contact, use that insight to refine future outreach.

5. Customize Your Value Proposition

🔹 Prospects in different tiers need different messaging.
🔹 Tailor your pitch based on pain points, urgency, and business size.
🔹 Focus on what resonates most with high-value leads.

📌 Example: If Tier 1 prospects prioritize ROI, lead with a business case showing financial impact.

6. Execute & Close More Deals

🔹 Now that you have ranked, sorted, and tailored your outreach—take action.
🔹 Engage top-tier prospects first. They are your best bet for hitting quota.
🔹 Adjust your process as you learn from real-world results.

📌 Every hour spent on the right prospects = faster deals and bigger wins.

🔥 Stop treating all prospects the same. Prioritize the right ones. Close bigger deals. 🔥

At Red2Black Group, we help sellers streamline prospecting and focus on high-value opportunities. Want to improve your win rate? Let’s talk. 🚀